What to Do with Your Old Jewelry: Redesign, Trade-In, or Treasure?

A Dallas Jeweler’s Guide to Giving Your Pieces New Purpose

At RS Diamond Broker, we often meet customers who open their jewelry boxes and find pieces they haven’t worn in years—gifts from the past, heirlooms out of style, or items tied to a chapter that’s closed. So the question becomes: what should you do with your old jewelry?

The good news? You have options. And none of them involve letting those pieces collect dust.

💍 Option 1: Redesign

Have a stone you love but a setting that feels outdated? We can help you breathe new life into your jewelry with a custom redesign. Maybe that engagement ring becomes a right-hand ring, or a vintage brooch transforms into a modern pendant.Why redesign:

• Keeps sentimental value

• Creates something truly “you”

• Cost-effective way to get a new piece

💎 Option 2: Trade-In

If your style has shifted or you’re ready for an upgrade, consider trading in your piece. We offer competitive value for diamonds, gold, and other precious metals, allowing you to put that toward something you’ll actually wear and love.Why trade-in:

• Fastest path to something new

• Great option for upgrading engagement rings or anniversary pieces

• No emotional ties to the original item

🧡 Option 3: Treasure It

Some pieces are better left untouched—and that’s okay. If a piece has emotional significance, we’ll help you clean, polish, and preserve it properly so it remains part of your family’s story.Why treasure:

• Keeps heritage alive

• Ideal for heirlooms or memory pieces

• Can still be worn on special occasions

Ready to Make a Decision?

Bring your old jewelry into RS Diamond Broker and we’ll walk you through your options with no pressure, just expert advice. Whether you want to refresh, replace, or retain—we’re here to help you make it meaningful.

📍 Visit our Dallas showroom or schedule a consultation today.